Form 14654 Example: How to Calculate the 5% Penalty

Form 14654 is the certification used for the Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures. It explains why the taxpayer’s conduct was non-willful and reports the calculation of the 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty. The penalty is generally 5% of the highest aggregate year-end value of the foreign financial assets included in the penalty base during the covered period.

The calculation is easy to state and easy to get wrong. It is not automatically 5% of the largest balance in any one account, and it is not based on the highest balance reached during the year. The work must be done account by account and year by year before the certification is signed.

Who uses Form 14654?

Form 14654 is for an eligible U.S. taxpayer using the Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures. In general, the taxpayer must have failed to report foreign financial assets and pay all tax due because of non-willful conduct, must not qualify as a nonresident for the foreign streamlined procedure, and must not be under an IRS civil examination or criminal investigation.

The domestic procedure normally involves amended returns for the most recent three years for which the due date has passed, delinquent or corrected FBARs for the most recent six years for which the due date has passed, payment of tax and interest, and the 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty reported on Form 14654.

If you live outside the United States, do not assume the domestic procedure applies. A taxpayer who meets the separate non-residency test may qualify for the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, which generally do not impose the 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty when all requirements are met.

How the Form 14654 penalty calculation works

The IRS calculation can be organized into four steps.

1. Identify the covered years

The penalty calculation generally looks at six covered FBAR years and three covered income-tax-return years. The exact years change as filing deadlines pass, so confirm the correct period for the submission rather than copying years from an older example.

2. Decide which accounts and assets enter the penalty base

Under the IRS instructions and streamlined domestic FAQs, the penalty base can include:

  • Foreign financial accounts in which the taxpayer had a personal financial interest that should have been, but were not, reported on an FBAR during a covered FBAR year.
  • Foreign financial assets that should have been, but were not, reported on Form 8938 during a covered tax-return year.
  • Foreign financial accounts or assets for which gross income was not reported during the relevant year.

An account does not automatically enter the base merely because it is foreign. Ownership, reporting requirements, the taxpayer’s personal financial interest, and whether the account and related income were reported all matter. The IRS FAQs also state that a value may be zero for a year when the account was FBAR compliant and, for one of the three covered return years, the asset and related income were properly reported on Form 8938 and Form 1040.

3. Use each covered asset’s December 31 value

For each covered year, list the December 31 balance or value in U.S. dollars for every asset included in the penalty base. Then total the included values for that year. This is different from using the highest balance that an account reached at any point during the year.

4. Select the highest annual total and multiply it by 5%

Compare the aggregate year-end totals for all six covered years. The highest annual total is generally the base for the 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty.

Form 14654 penalty example

Assume an eligible domestic streamlined filer determines that the following year-end amounts belong in the penalty base. These figures are simplified and are used only to illustrate the arithmetic.

Covered yearAggregate year-end value included in the penalty base
Year 1$80,000
Year 2$110,000
Year 3$140,000
Year 4$125,000
Year 5$90,000
Year 6$100,000

The highest aggregate year-end amount is $140,000. Multiplying $140,000 by 5% produces a miscellaneous offshore penalty of $7,000.

This example does not decide which accounts or assets belong in the base. That classification is usually the most important part of the calculation. A different ownership interest, reporting history, or item of unreported income can change the result.

Common Form 14654 calculation mistakes

  1. Using the highest balance during the year. The streamlined domestic calculation generally uses year-end balances or values.
  2. Looking at each account separately. The calculation compares the aggregate included value for each covered year.
  3. Including every foreign asset automatically. The penalty base depends on the reporting failure and the applicable FBAR, Form 8938, and income-reporting rules.
  4. Ignoring joint ownership. A taxpayer’s personal financial interest and the facts of joint ownership must be analyzed rather than assumed.
  5. Using the wrong covered years. The relevant years depend on which filing deadlines have passed when the submission is made.
  6. Treating the narrative as an afterthought. Form 14654 also requires a complete statement of facts explaining the non-willful conduct. The numbers and the narrative should be consistent.

What records should support the calculation?

A defensible calculation usually starts with year-end bank and brokerage statements, account-opening and ownership records, prior FBARs, Forms 8938, tax returns, information returns, and records of income generated by the foreign assets. Currency conversion workpapers and an account-by-account reconciliation help show how each annual total was reached.

Keep the workpapers with the submission file even when they are not all sent to the IRS. The IRS does not automatically audit streamlined submissions, but it may select one for examination or verify it against information received from banks and other sources.

Form 14654 frequently asked questions

Is the Form 14654 penalty always 5% of all foreign accounts?

No. The rate is generally 5%, but it is applied to the highest aggregate year-end value of the accounts and assets that belong in the penalty base. Determining what belongs in that base requires a review of the reporting failures for each year.

Does Form 14654 use the highest account balance?

Generally, no. The streamlined domestic calculation uses December 31 balances or values for included assets and compares the aggregate annual totals.

Can a taxpayer living abroad use Form 14654?

Possibly, but residence must be tested under the streamlined rules. A qualifying nonresident generally uses Form 14653 and the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures. Someone who lives abroad but does not satisfy the applicable non-residency test may need to consider the domestic procedure.

Is the non-willful statement part of Form 14654?

Yes. The taxpayer must provide specific facts explaining why the failure to report income, pay tax, and submit required information returns or FBARs resulted from non-willful conduct. The certification is signed under penalties of perjury.

Before you sign Form 14654

Confirm the covered years, reconcile each foreign account and asset, document why each value is included or excluded, calculate the annual totals, and make sure the penalty workpaper agrees with the certification and amended returns. If the facts may suggest intentional conduct, false statements, or concealment, obtain legal advice before making a streamlined submission.

Official IRS resources

This article provides general information and is not legal or tax advice. Eligibility and penalty treatment depend on the taxpayer’s complete facts.

robert-bye-jeF-vyxytb4-unsplash

How to Fix FBAR Errors?

There are several ways to fix an FBAR error. But some options are better than others (and some increase you chance of audit).

Subscribe to our newsletter for updates that will save you tax

Related topics

crypto taxes

Crypto Taxes – A Complete Guide

Cryptocurrency tax can be complicated, and the IRS is cracking down on crypto taxes violators. Learn everything you need to know about crypto taxes.